BeyondTrust

Security in Context: The BeyondTrust Blog

Welcome to Security in Context

Bringing you news and commentary on solutions and strategies for protecting critical IT infrastructure in the context of your business.

Does Compliance = Security?

Posted February 15, 2011    Peter McCalister

Since it’s hard to analyze the tradeoffs between security and productivity, IT organizations can fall back on gut feel, rules of thumb and past practices in making these decisions.  The easiest answer is frequently to just follow the rules and regulations so you remain in compliance with industry regulations or current policies.  As a result, compliance becomes a substitute for security. But are they really equal?  Does being in compliance mean you have a secure IT environment?

I see a number of major challenges when staying in compliance is substituted for a well thought out IT security strategy. First, compliance oriented policies tend to be backward looking making sure that past problems don’t reoccur but do little to help anticipate new threats. Compliance also focuses on process rather than results, in many cases with a heavy emphasis on record keeping. And focusing on compliance can stifle innovation because new security techniques are needed to deal with new technical approaches.

Now don’t get me wrong. Staying in compliance is a good thing to do. It’s essential in many businesses. And the rigor that comes with staying in compliance is a necessary element of good security strategy. Maintaining SAS 70 Type II compliance, for example, lets everyone in the organization know that key processes are important and gives everyone an independent perspective of whether an organization is doing what they say they are going to doAnd while it’s often joked about, a compliance mandate often pays the bills for real security. If that’s what it takes to upgrade key infrastructure, that’s good too.

But it’s clear that compliance doesn’t equal good security.  According to Jim Jaeger, director of DoD & Commercial Cyber Solutions for General Dynamics Advanced Information Systems,  “Virtually every breach we investigate, that company has been certified as being compliant within the last year.”  And at its worst, Jaeger sees that “these compliance regimes give people an incredible false sense of security.”

So compliance is a great way set a minimum bar for security policies. But you need to take into account the real value of your data and the threats that face your industry and particular business.  So we are back to having to do that difficult analysis on the real costs and benefits of security. And while there is no simple answer there may be a different way to frame the problem.  Can you implement security in a way that enhances productivity?   Wouldn’t that be great!   The good news is that most of the trade-offs can be mitigated by implementing a privilege identity management solution.

Leave a Reply

Additional articles

red-thumbprint

Why big data breaches won’t always be so easy

Posted September 19, 2014    Byron Acohido

This blog post is republished with the permission of ThirdCertainty. See the original post here. – Why big data breaches won’t always be so easy By: Byron Acohido, Editor-In-Chief, ThirdCertainty Some day, perhaps fairly soon, it will be much more difficult for data thieves to pull off capers like the headline-grabbing hacks of Home Depot and Target….

Tags:
, , , , ,
pbps-blog2

8 Reasons Your Privileged Password Management Solution Will Fail

Posted September 18, 2014    Chris Burd

Leveraging complex, frequently updated passwords is a basic security best practice for protecting privileged accounts in your organization. But if passwords are such a no-brainer, why do two out of three data breaches tie back to poor password management? The fact is that not all privileged password management strategies are created equal, so it’s critical…

Tags:
, , , , , ,
pbps-customer-campaign-image

You Change Your Oil Regularly; Why Not Your Passwords?

Posted September 11, 2014    Chris Burd

There are many things in life that get changed regularly:  your car oil, toothbrush and hopefully, your bed sheets.  It’s rare that you give these things much thought – even when you forget to change them. But what if you’re forgetting something that can cost you millions of dollars if left unchanged for long periods…

Tags:
, , ,